(317) 888-1040 7610 Madison Ave, Indianapolis, IN Mon–Thu 8:30–5 · Fri 8:30–4
★★★★★ 4.8 on Google · Serving Central Indiana since 1978
Independent Insurance Agency · Central Indiana

Insurance that works
for you.

Trusted protection for your home, auto, business, and life — from Central Indiana's most experienced independent agency.

Get Your Free Quote Call or Text (317) 888-1040
Serving Central Indiana since 1978
Indiana-licensed independent agents
100+ years combined experience
$0 extra cost — carriers pay our fee
Killion & Hall Insurance Agency office sign, 7610 Madison Avenue
4.8 ★★★★★
Rated on
Google
40+ Years serving
Central Indiana

What would you like to insure?

Home & Auto Bundle & save
→
Auto Cars, trucks & more
→
Home Owners & renters
→
Life Term & whole life
→
What We Cover
Home & auto bundles New teen drivers Rental & vacant properties Business liability High-value homes Life insurance Umbrella coverage Boat & watercraft Condo & renters Multi-policy discounts
5,000+
Neighbors & businesses
insured across Central Indiana
40+
Years serving
Central Indiana
10+
Top-rated insurance
carriers represented
100%
Independent — we work
for you, not one insurer
4.8★
Average rating
on Google Reviews
Mike Hall, Principal Agent at Killion & Hall Insurance Agency
100+ Years combined
team experience
1981 Licensed
since
Why Killion & Hall

On your side, every step of the way.

Unlike captive agents who represent just one company, we're 100% independent — which means we shop dozens of top-rated carriers to find the best coverage at the best price for you. Principal agent Mike Hall has led the agency since 1981, and our team carries that same hands-on approach into every policy we write.

Talk to an Agent
01

Truly Independent

We represent you — not any single insurance company. That means unbiased advice and the widest selection of coverage options.

02

Expert Guidance

Principal agent Mike Hall has been licensed since 1981. Our staff brings over 100 years of combined insurance experience to every client.

03

No Hidden Costs

Our services are completely free to you. Insurance carriers compensate us directly — so you get expert help at zero extra cost.

★ Neighborhood Favorite

Trusted by Central Indiana
families since 1978.

Formed in 2016 by the merger of Killion Insurance (est. 1984) and Hall Insurance (est. 1978), we bring decades of deep local knowledge and long-term client relationships to every policy we write.

Location7610 Madison Ave, Indianapolis
Call or Text(317) 888-1040
Mon – Thu8:30 AM – 5:00 PM
Friday8:30 AM – 4:00 PM
What We Cover

Coverage for every part of your life.

From your daily commute to your business, your home to your family's future — we've got you covered with personalized policies that fit your needs.

Home Insurance

Your home is your most valuable asset. We find you the right combination of coverage, service, and competitive pricing — including specialty dwelling policies for rentals and vacant properties.

Get a quote →

Auto Insurance

Car insurance covers more than just your vehicle. We do all the heavy lifting — comparing multiple carriers to find the best coverage and price, at no extra cost to you.

Get a quote →

Business Insurance

From general liability and contractors coverage to commercial auto and restaurant insurance — we protect businesses of all sizes with the best-fit carrier for your industry.

Get a quote →

Life Insurance

Protect the people who depend on you. We do a comprehensive needs analysis, then survey the marketplace to find the best policy at the best price for your situation.

Get a quote →

Boat & Watercraft

Whether it's a speedboat, personal watercraft, or sailboat — we'll find the right coverage for your time on the water with specialty watercraft policies from top Indiana carriers.

Get a quote →

Condo & Renters

Protect your belongings and liability beyond what your building's master policy covers. We'll make sure you're fully protected with the right condo or renters policy.

Get a quote →
How It Works

Getting covered is simple.

We handle the complexity of the insurance marketplace so you don't have to.

1

Call, text, or stop in

Call or text us at (317) 888-1040, or visit our Madison Avenue office. We'll start with a conversation about what you need to protect.

2

We shop the market for you

As an independent agency representing 10+ carriers, we compare rates and coverage options — at no cost to you.

3

Get your personalized recommendation

Our licensed agents walk you through the best options and explain exactly what's covered — in plain English.

4

You're covered — and we stay in touch

We handle everything from policy setup to claims support. We're your long-term partner, not a one-time transaction.

One agency.
Many options.

Unlike a captive agent who can only offer products from one company, our 100% independent status means we can write policies with many of Indiana's highest-rated carriers — giving you real choice and real savings.

Carriers we represent
Travelers Progressive Safeco Nationwide Auto-Owners Erie Grange Foremost And more...
Request a Quote

Let's find you the right coverage.

Leave your name and number and one of our licensed agents will call you back — no pressure, no obligation.

Free, no-obligation consultation
We shop 10+ carriers for you
Local Central Indiana agents, not a call center
Rather call or text? (317) 888-1040

Which coverage are you interested in?

We'll call you back within one business day.

What Our Clients Say

Central Indiana neighbors trust us.

4.8
★★★★★ Google Reviews
★★★★★

"Aaron took the time to explain a few options that Erie offers to achieve a lower rate. He ended up saving me so much more than I would have imagined. Aaron was extremely kind and patient and answered all of my questions."

Lois B.
Google Review
★★★★★

"Mike customized both the home and auto policies. My liability limits were doubled or tripled in most areas — AND we saved over $300.00 annually. If you are looking for complete coverage with great customer service, call this agency!"

Carole M.
Google Review
★★★★★

"The staff is extremely professional and helpful. I've been with this company since it was Hall Insurance in 1985. I've remained because of the people and their dedication."

Tom M.
Google Review
★★★★★

"They have a great staff that go above and beyond to help you. We have been with them for over 25 years. They have ALWAYS been helpful."

Mary B.
Google Review
★★★★★ "Great group of people, have been going there for 19 years." — Jenny H.
★★★★★ "Great people, great service!" — Juanita F.
Nextdoor Neighborhood Favorite 2022 & 2023
Ready to get started?

Your best rate
is one call away.

Talk to a licensed agent today — no pressure, no obligation. We'll find the coverage that fits your life and your budget.

Call or Text (317) 888-1040 Find Our Office

Visit Our Madison Avenue Office

Conveniently located on the south side, our team is here Monday through Friday to help Central Indiana families and businesses with quotes, policy questions, claims support, and more.

Address 7610 Madison Avenue, Indianapolis, IN 46227
Call or Text (317) 888-1040
Hours Monday – Thursday: 8:30 AM – 5:00 PM
Friday: 8:30 AM – 4:00 PM
Email mike@killionhall.com

7610 Madison Avenue

Indianapolis, IN 46227

Open in Maps